‘As an Emboldened Ukraine Takes Repeated Aim at the Heart of the Russian Arctic, Could Circumpolar Exclusion Catalyze an Unprecedented and Uncontrolled Arctic Escalation Reminiscent of Sarajevo 1914? Or Might Arctic Exceptionalism Reassert Itself and Inspire an Arctic Co-Management Framework for Peace in Ukraine Modeled on Svalbard 1920?
The Illogic of Circumpolar Exclusion—Why Isolating Russia Endangers the Arctic Order
For over three centuries, the circumpolar Arctic has defied the orthodoxies of classical power politics, evolving into an enduring zone of collaborative governance, diplomatic moderation, and transnational co-management even during periods of acute global friction (Zellen 2024a). Across the violent upheavals of the twentieth century—including two World Wars and the nuclear standoff of the Cold War—the states and peoples of the Far North repeatedly discovered that the harsh realities of polar geography compelled pragmatic accommodation rather than zero-sum confrontation (Zellen 2009a; Zellen 2024a). Yet in the wake of Russia’s brutal invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Western policymakers hastily dismantled this hard-won regional architecture. By suspending participation in the Arctic Council during Moscow’s chairmanship, severing bilateral scientific and diplomatic channels, and reorienting national Arctic strategies around the containment of Russia, the seven Western Arctic states—the so-called “A7″—embraced a policy of circumpolar isolation (Zellen 2023; Zellen 2024b). While motivated by understandable moral outrage over Russian aggression in Eastern Europe, the effort to quarantine Russia from the Arctic is a profound strategic miscalculation. Far from weakening Moscow or protecting northern security, isolating Russia is geographically untenable, environmentally perilous, damaging to Indigenous sovereignty, and strategically counterproductive.
The Illusion of a “Half-Arctic” Order
Any coherent strategy for the Far North must begin with an unyielding geographic and demographic reality: Russia is not a peripheral actor in the Arctic; it is half of the circumpolar world (Zellen 2023). Spanning eleven time zones across northern Eurasia, the Russian Federation accounts for roughly half of the Arctic’s coastline, half of its terrestrial landmass, half of its regional economic output, and approximately half of its total population (Zellen 2009a; Zellen 2023). From the Kola Peninsula in the west to the Bering Strait in the east, Moscow exercises sovereign jurisdiction over the longest stretch of the Northern Sea Route and holds vast reserves of hydrocarbons, strategic minerals, and freshwater (Zellen 2013).
To imagine that the remaining seven Arctic states can construct a viable, comprehensive regime for polar governance while excluding the nation that comprises half the region is an exercise in geopolitical fantasy (Zellen 2023; Zellen 2024a). In earlier eras, when the Arctic remained locked beneath perennial sea ice and isolated from global commerce, great powers could afford to treat the polar basin as an empty strategic buffer or a frozen frontier (Zellen 2009a; Zellen 2011). That era has vanished. As rapid anthropogenic warming transforms the Arctic Ocean from a solid ice cap into a navigable maritime domain, the region has become deeply integrated into global shipping, resource extraction, and environmental systems (Zellen 2008; Zellen 2013). Attempting to govern an interconnected polar ecosystem through a “half-Arctic” diplomatic framework leaves half of the circumpolar world outside international norms, regulatory mechanisms, and transparency regimes. One cannot manage a shared ocean, regulate transboundary fisheries, or enforce maritime safety standards by pretending that its largest littoral state does not exist (Zellen 2023).
The Resilience—and Necessity—of Arctic Exceptionalism
Since 2022, a chorus of commentators and security analysts has declared the death of “Arctic exceptionalism”—the long-standing principle that the Far North should remain insulated from geopolitical conflicts erupting at lower latitudes so that regional stakeholders can cooperate on shared challenges (Zellen 2024a). This obituary is both premature and dangerous. Arctic exceptionalism was never a naive expression of liberal utopianism, nor was it dependent on harmonious relations between Washington and Moscow (Zellen 2024a). Rather, it emerged from a hard-nosed realist recognition that the extreme physical environment of the North imposes steep costs on unilateralism and rewards collective risk management (Zellen 2009a; Zellen 2024a).
Even during the darkest chapters of the Cold War, when American and Soviet strategic bombers and ballistic missile submarines patrolled beneath and above the polar ice cap, the superpowers still found ways to cooperate on polar science, environmental protection, and Indigenous cultural exchanges—culminating in Mikhail Gorbachev’s landmark 1987 Murmansk Initiative, which envisioned the Arctic as a “zone of peace” (Zellen 2009a; Zellen 2024a). That vision bore institutional fruit in the 1991 Arctic Environmental Protection Strategy and the 1996 Ottawa Declaration establishing the Arctic Council, which deliberately excluded military security from its mandate in order to preserve a diplomatic sanctuary for environmental and human security cooperation (AEPS 1991; Arctic Council 1996; Zellen 2013; Zellen 2024a).
By allowing the war in Ukraine to paralyze the Arctic Council, the A7 states sacrificed one of the world’s few remaining diplomatic “off-ramps”—a low-tension institutional forum where senior Western and Russian officials could maintain dialogue, build trust, and manage crises before they escalated into direct military confrontation (Zellen 2023; Zellen 2024a). History demonstrates that great powers need structured arenas for communication precisely when their broader bilateral relationships are most fractured (Zellen 2011; Zellen 2012). Dismantling the diplomatic guardrails of the Far North does not punish Moscow for its conduct in Ukraine; it merely eliminates an essential shock absorber that has kept the Arctic free of armed interstate conflict for generations (Zellen 2024a).
Climate Change Does Not Respect Diplomatic Boycotts
The most immediate casualty of Russia’s diplomatic isolation is the global struggle against climate change. The Arctic is warming nearly four times faster than the global average, triggering cascading environmental disruptions—from the collapse of summer sea ice and accelerating Greenlandic ice-sheet melt to massive boreal wildfires and the thawing of carbon-rich permafrost (Zellen 2008; Zellen 2009a; Zellen 2023). These phenomena pose an existential threat not only to northern communities, but to coastal cities, agricultural systems, and weather patterns across the entire planet (Zellen 2009a).
Yet climate science cannot be conducted with a blind spot covering half the polar basin (Zellen 2023). When Western institutions froze scientific partnerships, data-sharing agreements, and joint field expeditions with Russian researchers after 2022, they severed access to critical monitoring stations across Siberia and the Russian Arctic coast. Without continuous data on Russian permafrost thaw, methane emissions, riverine discharge into the Arctic Ocean, and migratory wildlife patterns, global climate models lose accuracy at the exact moment humanity needs high-resolution predictive clarity (Zellen 2023; Zellen 2024a). Furthermore, as retreating sea ice opens the Northern Sea Route and adjacent waters to increased tanker traffic, fishing fleets, and adventure tourism, the suspension of joint search-and-rescue exercises and oil-spill response coordination between Russia and its neighbors invites catastrophic human and ecological disaster (Zellen 2013; Zellen 2023). Nature does not observe diplomatic boycotts; an oil spill in the Bering Strait or a runaway methane release in the Siberian tundra will not stop at an invisible Cold War boundary line (Zellen 2023).
Subverting the Fourth Image: The Cost to Arctic Indigenous Peoples
Any assessment of Arctic governance must look beyond the traditional Westphalian state system to what I have termed the “fourth image” of international relations—the enduring agency of Indigenous polities, tribal nations, and sub-state actors whose homelands span modern national borders (Zellen 2008; Zellen 2009b; Zellen 2024a). Long before European empires and modern nation-states drew sovereignty lines across the tundra and pack ice, Inuit, Sámi, Gwich’in, Athabaskan, and Russian Indigenous peoples sustained intricate networks of trade, kinship, and environmental stewardship across the circumpolar North (Zellen 2008; Zellen 2009b).
Over the past half-century, through landmark land claims settlements in Alaska, Canada, and Greenland, Indigenous peoples reclaimed substantial political authority and co-management rights over their ancestral territories (Zellen 2008; Zellen 2009b; Zellen 2025b). This resurgence found its highest international expression in the Arctic Council, where six Indigenous Permanent Participant organizations—including the Inuit Circumpolar Council, the Saami Council, the Aleut International Association, and the Russian Association of Indigenous Peoples of the North (RAIPON)—sit at the diplomatic table alongside sovereign states (Zellen 2009b; Zellen 2024a). This multilevel architecture transformed the Arctic into a global model for post-colonial reconciliation and participatory governance (Zellen 2024a; Zellen 2025b).
Isolating Russia strikes at the heart of this achievement. Dividing the circumpolar world into hostile Eastern and Western blocs once again imposes an artificial “Ice Curtain” across traditional Indigenous homelands—separating Alaskan Yupik and Inupiat communities from their kin in Chukotka, and fracturing pan-Arctic Indigenous solidarity (Zellen 2009b; Zellen 2024b). When state-level rivalries sideline the Arctic Council, Indigenous Permanent Participants lose their premier international platform for shaping policies that directly affect their food security, cultural survival, and self-determination (Zellen 2023; Zellen 2024a). Re-militarizing the North and reducing Arctic diplomacy to a contest between NATO and Moscow marginalizes the very peoples who have inhabited and stewarded the region for millennia (Zellen 2024a; Zellen 2025c).
The Strategic Backfire: NATO Expansion and the Sino-Russian Entente
From a strictly realist perspective, the Western policy of Arctic isolation has also produced severe unintended strategic consequences. Following the accession of Finland and Sweden into NATO, seven of the eight Arctic states are now members of the Western military alliance, transforming the geopolitical map of the High North into a stark binary division between “NATO Arctic” and “Russian Arctic” (Zellen 2024b; Zellen 2025c). While celebrated in Western capitals as a triumph of allied unity, this rapid expansion of NATO’s northern footprint risks triggering a classic security dilemma (Zellen 2024b; Zellen 2025a).
Confronted with an enlarged military alliance along its northwestern frontier and excluded from regional diplomatic institutions, Moscow inevitably views its Arctic bastions—particularly the Kola Peninsula, home to Russia’s Northern Fleet and sea-based nuclear deterrent—as increasingly vulnerable (Zellen 2011; Zellen 2025c). Rather than compelling Russia to retreat or moderate its behavior, diplomatic ostracization incentivizes Moscow to double down on military fortification in the High North, rely more heavily on nuclear deterrence to offset conventional inferiority, and abandon cooperative restraint (Zellen 2024a; Zellen 2025c).
Simultaneously, Western efforts to isolate Russia economically and diplomatically have accelerated a strategic alignment that Washington has long sought to prevent: the deepening partnership between Russia and China in the Arctic (Zellen 2024b; Zellen 2025c). Cut off from Western capital, maritime technology, and energy markets, Moscow has turned to Beijing as its primary financier, infrastructure partner, and customer for Arctic liquefied natural gas and Northern Sea Route transit. Ironically, American policies driven by zero-sum hostility toward both Moscow and Beijing have pushed the two Eurasian powers into closer polar coordination, granting China unprecedented economic and strategic leverage across the Russian Arctic while depriving the West of visibility into their joint activities (Zellen 2024b; Zellen 2025c).
Bibliography
Arctic Council. Declaration on the Establishment of the Arctic Council (Ottawa Declaration). Ottawa, Canada, September 19, 1996.
Arctic Environmental Protection Strategy (AEPS). Declaration on the Protection of the Arctic Environment. Rovaniemi, Finland, June 14, 1991.
BBC News. “How Ukraine Carried Out Daring ‘Spider Web’ Attack on Russian Bombers.” June 2, 2025.
Government of Canada. Agreement Between the Inuit of the Nunavut Settlement Area and Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada (Nunavut Land Claims Agreement). Iqaluit, May 25, 1993.
Government of Canada and Kingdom of Denmark. Agreement Between the Government of Canada and the Government of the Kingdom of Denmark Regarding the Boundary in the Area Between Greenland and Canada (Hans Island / Tartupaluk Agreement). Ottawa, June 14, 2022.
High North News. “Reports of Drone Attacks Near Northern Norway.” September 13, 2024.
High North News. “Ukraine War Reaches Arctic With Massive Drone Attack on Olenya Air Base Near Murmansk.” June 2, 2025.
Humpert, Malte. “Ukraine’s Deepest Drone Strike Reaches Russia’s Arctic Gas Heartland.” High North News, September 16, 2026.
Khomenko, Ivan. “Ukrainian Drones Leave Russian Missile Warship Unable to Sail, With Crew Dead and Wounded.” United24 Media, November 14, 2026.
New Voice of Ukraine. “Estonian Military Reveals Details of Ukrainian Drone Strike on Russian Missile Ship in Gulf of Finland.” November 14, 2026.
Ophaug, Linn. “Russian Oil Exports Surge Along Arctic Route.” High North News, October 21, 2026.
Reuters. “Russian Oil Exports by Arctic Route Jump Amid World Freight Crisis, Data Shows.” October 19, 2026.
Treaty Concerning the Archipelago of Spitsbergen (Svalbard Treaty). Signed at Paris, February 9, 1920. League of Nations Treaty Series, vol. 2, no. 41, pp. 7–19.
Tuchman, Barbara W. The Guns of August. New York: Macmillan, 1962.
Ukrainska Pravda. “Ukraine Hits Russian Gas Plants 3,000 km Away in Record Strike.” September 9, 2026.
United States Congress. Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (ANCSA). Public Law 92-203, 85 Stat. 688. Enacted December 18, 1971.
United States and Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. Agreement Between the United States of America and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics on the Maritime Boundary. Signed at Washington, D.C., June 1, 1990.
Zellen, Barry Scott. Breaking the Ice: From Land Claims to Tribal Sovereignty in the Arctic. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 2008.
Zellen, Barry Scott. Arctic Doom, Arctic Boom: The Geopolitics of Climate Change in the Arctic. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger, 2009a.
Zellen, Barry Scott. On Thin Ice: The Inuit, the State, and the Challenge of Arctic Sovereignty. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 2009b.
Zellen, Barry Scott. State of Doom: Bernard Brodie, the Bomb, and the Birth of the Bipolar World. New York: Continuum, 2011.
Zellen, Barry Scott. The Art of War in an Asymmetric World: Strategy for the Post-Cold War Era. New York: Continuum, 2012.
Zellen, Barry Scott, ed. The Fast-Changing Arctic: Rethinking Arctic Security for a Warmer World. Calgary: University of Calgary Press, 2013.
Zellen, Barry Scott. “As War in Ukraine Upends a Quarter Century of Enduring Arctic Cooperation, the World Needs the Whole Arctic Council Now More Than Ever.” The Northern Review, no. 54 (2023): 137–160.
Zellen, Barry Scott. Arctic Exceptionalism: Cooperation in a Contested World. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2024a.
Zellen, Barry Scott. “The Dark Side of NATO Expansion – Part I.” The Arctic Institute, October 29, 2024b.
Zellen, Barry Scott. “Arctic March of Folly? Misperceptions and Apprehensions Torpedo America’s Goodwill Mission to Greenland After Stunning Election Turnabout.” The Arctic Institute, April 2025a.
Zellen, Barry Scott. “From Knowledge to Power: Co-management, Knowledge Co-production, and the Re-empowerment of Arctic Indigenous Peoples.” The Arctic Institute, May 20, 2025b.
Zellen, Barry Scott. “NATO in the Arctic.” Intersec: The Journal of International Security, July/August 2025c, pp. 22–24.