- No easy road: easements and occupation in the West Bank Irfan Khawaja, Policy of Truth
- Clouds over the Pacific: War, Stagnation, and the end of the Asian Century James Holmes, National Review
- Was philosophy founded by non-Western women? Dag Herbjørnsrud, Aeon
- Natural History of a Cherry Tree Nick Nielsen, Grand Strategy Annex
Irfan Khawaja has a good argument on Yoram Hazony’s new book on nationalism, which is being thoroughly and thoughtfully dissected by Arnold Kling:
Does anyone understand the point that Kling and/or Hazony are making about the relation between legitimacy based on voluntary acceptance, and consent? On the one hand, the claim is that in a legitimate government, we obey the law “voluntarily”; on the other hand, the claim is that we do not consent to government. How can we not consent to government if we obey it voluntarily? Coming the other way around: how can we obey it voluntarily if we don’t consent to it? Even if Hazony wants to broaden consent beyond the Lockean account, that’s still a broadening of the conditions of consent, not a nullification of the role of consent. The combination of claims that Kling attributes to Hazony does not seem coherent.
As a reminder, this is not a philosophical argument. Well, it is but it isn’t. I suspect this is about Israel and Palestine as much as it is about logical rigor. Stay tuned, and don’t be shy about having your say!
- A new history of Islamic Spain Peter Gordon, Asian Review of Books
- A Palestinian perspective on Labour’s anti-Semitism row Nimer Sultany, Disorder of Things
- The crumbling of French culture Guillaume de Thieulloy, Law & Liberty
- Can Asia and Europe make America’s alliances great again? Tongfi Kim, the Diplomat
- Before Indiana Jones came Abraham Hyacinthe Anquetil-Duperron Blake Smith, Aeon
- Can economists and humanists ever be friends? John Lanchester, New Yorker
- A Guaranteed Income would undermine the social virtues of work John McGinnis, Law & Liberty
- On Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Palestine, and the Left Corey Robin, Crooked Timber