Skip to content

Notes On Liberty

Spontaneous thoughts on a humble creed

  • Home
  • About the Consortium
  • Consulting
    • Geopolitical strategy and risk
      • Tridivesh Singh Maini
    • Grant writing
      • Kevin Kallmes
  • Longform Essays
    • Libertarians and Pragmatists on Democracy
    • Systemic Racism: a Rationalist Take
    • Why Republican Libertarianism?
    • Myths of Sovereignty and British Isolation
    • Institutions, Machines, and Complex Orders
    • Legal Immigration Into the United States
    • Poverty Under Democratic Socialism
    • The State in education
    • Three Lessons on Institutions and Incentives
    • Protectionism; Free Trade, Step by Step
  • Resources
    • Be Our Guest
      • Elizabeth Warren's Degrading Diversity Plans
      • Food & Drinks to Rats & Finks
      • Government: The Great Post-Christian Swindle
      • How to make Brexit Really Worthwhile – Example: Regulation dealing with Information Asymmetries
      • How to make Brexit Really Worthwhile – Example: Financial Regulation
      • Liberty, Government, and Technology: 2019
      • Of Monies and Juries and Freedoms
      • Privacy in a Shared World: Vacillating on Vaccines
      • Providing healthcare isn’t practicing medicine
      • Resolved: Human Government is Despotism
      • Rights and Government Confiscation During COVID-19
      • Sailing a Catholic Ship on Modern Seas
      • Suing Juul Won’t Solve Anything
      • The Tyrant’s Burden
      • The U.S. Economy: A Fading Illusion?
      • Those Astonishing Reversals on the Political Left
      • What’s the Voter’s Value?
  • About the Notewriters
    • Shree Agnihotri
    • Alexander Albrecht
    • Ethan Blevins
    • Joakim Book
    • Brandon Christensen
    • Lode Cossaer
    • Nick Cowen
    • Mary Lucia Darst
    • Andre Van Doren
    • Jacques Delacroix
    • Lucas G. Freire
    • Vincent Geloso
    • Edwin van de Haar
    • Kevin Kallmes
    • Mark Koyama
    • Michelango Landgrave
    • Chhay Lin Lim
    • Adrián Lucardi
    • Ash Navabi
    • Tridivesh Singh Maini
    • Bill Rein
    • Bruno Gonçalves Rosi
    • Barry Stocker
    • Federico Sosa Valle
    • Aris Trantidis
    • Derrill Watson
    • Rick Weber
    • Zak Woodman
    • Andrei Znamenski
    • Guest Notewriters
HomePosts tagged 'monolithic social and intellectual reality'

monolithic social and intellectual reality

The Yellow Vests Movement in France

12/10/201812/10/2018 Jacques Delacroix Current Events, Politics France, French politics, ideology, monolithic social and intellectual reality, taxation, welfare state, Yellow Vests

President Macron spoke to the French nation today (12/10/18). He apologized a little for his figurative distance from the rank-and-file. Then he tried to buy some off the yellow vests off with other people’s money. The national minimum monthly wage will rise by about US$113; overtime will not be taxed anymore. You are not going to believe the next appeasement measure he announced. I have a hard time believing it myself but I read it and heard it from several sources. President Macron decreed a significant Christmas bonus for public servants and ordered (I think) private employers to follow suite. The bonus will also be tax-free. I have no idea what effects these measures will have. I suspect the weather has more influence on the yellow vests’ behavior.

The movement began, as most Americans know by now, as a protest against a new extra tax on diesel fuel. It was presented a little breathlessly as a way to save the planet. This is significant in several ways. First, it suggests that a large fraction of the French people do not believe in climate change (like me) or do not care about it. Second, it demonstrates that Mr Macron, probably along with the political class in general, have lost touch with much of their electorate for not realizing the these perceptions. Third, it shows sheer incompetence if not cynicism. Any average thinking person in France could have warned Mr Macron that a tax on diesel is one of the most regressive taxes possible. The transport of ordinary goods in France relies largely on diesel-powered trucks. A tax on diesel proportionately (proportionately) hits the poor more than the prosperous. Perhaps the government thought that those affected were too stupid or too passive to protest.

The government has reversed its decision on the diesel tax but it’s too late. It seems to me the diesel tax was simply a case of the straw that broke the camel back. Fifty years ago, the French gave themselves a wonderful cradle-to-grave summer camp. It’s a real good one, I must say, including a sort of winter camp of free ski vacations for children. (Would I make this up?) This was based on the original idea that “the rich” could be taxed into paying for summer camp. (Sounds familiar?) After two generations, the bills are finally coming due. The definition of “the rich” has been going down fast. Indirect (and therefore regressive) taxes are everywhere. The increase in the tax on diesel was just one of the latest.

The providential and fun state has other consequences. The main one is that it is implicitly anti-business. It protects employees almost completely against being laid off. It’s solicitous of their leisure with a 34 hour week and many many vacations and holidays. French governing circles have become used to celebrating GDP growth rates so low they are considered shameful in America. I think it’s rigorously true that in the past twenty years, unemployment has never gone below 8%. It’s normally been closer to 9% and even 10%. It’s 20% if you are young. I am guessing (guessing) that it’s 40% and up if you are young and your name is Mohammed.

There is worse. In a pattern that will seem familiar to many Americans, there is a big well-being divide between the capital, Paris proper, and the rest of France. Parisians live in a low-density city with good public transport and many employment opportunities. Housing prices and rents are high in Paris, as you might expect. In nearly all of the rest of France, there are few jobs, spotty services. (I am told it’s not uncommon to have to drive 2 hours each way to consult a specialist); hospitals are good but far and few. Many of those charming villages you see from the freeway have not had schools for many years. Housing in the hinterland is cheap. Of course, this is enough to cause people of low means to be stuck where they are.

It’s difficult for foreign reporters to understand the yellow vests movement, for a small reason and for a big one. First, it does seem to be originally a genuine grassroot movement. Accordingly, it has no leaders and not authorized spokespersons. Second, and much more importantly, in my lifetime the very conceptual vocabulary of market economies has vanished from the public discourse. The yellow vests interviewed on television do not know how to express what hurts them. When ordinary French men and women, and what passes for their intellectual elites, discuss, or even think, about economic problems the only tools they have at their disposal is the pseudo-Marxist vocabulary of those who got their Marxism from Cliff Notes (if that). I think there is only one small French group (on Facebook) that is able to evade this conceptual tyranny. In France, thinking in terms of vaguely socialist terms has ceased to be a choice. It’s now a monolithic social and intellectual reality.

I don’t see how even a more determined and more talented political leader than Mr Macron can tell the great mass of the French people: Summer camp is over; everybody go home and learn to make do with less free stuff. Then, re-learn work.

With all this, France is a functioning democracy. The French elected Macron after six years of disastrous “Socialist” Party rule. Perhaps, as has been the case before, the French people -with their historical inability to reform- will be the canary in the mine for everyone else: The big generous state based on taxation is bad for you or for your children. Just ask the French.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...
1 Comment

Search Bar

Follow Us

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed

Enter Your E-Mail Address, Then Click "The Box"

Join 5,772 other followers

Discussion

  • Jack Curtis on Nightcap
  • Brandon Christensen on Nightcap
  • Jack Curtis on Nightcap
  • Who’s Afraid of Postmodernism? – The Emory Whig on “Foucault’s Pendulum”: Social Scholarship, Ideology, and Libertarian Temptations
  • Kevin Kallmes on Pandemics and Hyperinflations
  • Jack Curtis on Nightcap
  • Jack Curtis on Pandemics and Hyperinflations
  • Pandemics and Hyperinflations – Rational Review News Digest on Pandemics and Hyperinflations
  • Pandemics and Hyperinflations | Notes On Liberty on Hyperinflation and trust in Ancient Rome
  • Unequal But Not As Unequal on Interwar US inequality data are deeply flawed

Popular Notes

  • Conservatives vs Liberals vs Libertarians
  • Eye Candy: Most popular porn categories, by country, in 2019
  • Some problems with postmodernism
  • The Year is 1534, and...
  • Libertarianism and Neoliberalism – A difference that matters?

Classic Notes

  • (Christensen) Colonialism: Myths and Realities
  • (Delacroix) Legal Immigration Into the United States
  • (Weber) Gun control: Centralized vs. Dispersed
  • (Geloso) A flaw regarding the chance of “out-earning” your parents
  • (Stocker) Tacitus on Barbarian Liberty
  • (Rosi) The Protestant Reformation and freedom of conscience, II
  • (Landgrave) What is a nation?
  • (Rein) White rappers and hip hop culture
  • (Lim) Early childhood memories of a Cambodian refugee camp
  • (Van de Haar) Classical Liberalism and the Nation State
  • (Sosa Valle) Three Lessons on Institutions and Incentives
  • (Maini) The EU’s laudable Asia Connectivity Strategy
  • (Cowen) Public Choice and Market Failure
  • (Book) Mr. Darcy’s Ten Thousand a Year
  • (Woodman) Libertarians and Pragmatists on Democracy
  • (Kallmes) The Myth of the Nazi War Machine
  • (Koyama) The End of the Past
  • (Darst) Semiotics in national dialogue: an observation
  • (Blevins) Spaghetti Monsters and Free Exercise
  • (Navabi) Three Short Stories on Housing Economics
  • (Watson) Romance Econometrics
  • (Albrecht) Libertarianism and Neoliberalism – A difference that matters?
  • (Freire) Economics in the ancient world?
  • (Znamenski) “Foucault’s Pendulum”: Social Scholarship, Ideology, and Libertarian Temptations
  • (Agnihotri) Courts as Modern Civic Churches?
  • (Lucardi) What is the best book about Argentina?
  • (Cossaer) On the trade off between the rule of law and lower taxes
  • (Trantidis) Rawls, Antigone, and the tragic irony of norms

Our Recent Books

  • Socialism as a Secular Creed: A Modern Global History (2021) Socialism as a Secular Creed: A Modern Global History (2021)
  • Blockchain Basics Book (2020) Blockchain Basics Book (2020)
  • Rethinking Canadian Economic Growth and Development since 1900: The Quebec Case (2017) Rethinking Canadian Economic Growth and Development since 1900: The Quebec Case (2017)
  • Philosophy of the Novel (2018) Philosophy of the Novel (2018)
  • Persecution and Toleration: The Long Road to Religious Freedom (2019) Persecution and Toleration: The Long Road to Religious Freedom (2019)
  • Clientelism and Economic Policy: Greece and the Crisis (2016) Clientelism and Economic Policy: Greece and the Crisis (2016)
  • Degrees of Freedom: Liberal Political Philosophy and Ideology (2015) Degrees of Freedom: Liberal Political Philosophy and Ideology (2015)
  • Kierkegaard on Politics (2014) Kierkegaard on Politics (2014)
  • Nietzsche as Political Philosopher (2014) Nietzsche as Political Philosopher (2014)
  • Rousseau on Language and Writing: Two Perspectives (2014) Rousseau on Language and Writing: Two Perspectives (2014)
  • I Used to Be French: An Immature Autobiography (2014) I Used to Be French: An Immature Autobiography (2014)
  • Les pumas de grande banlieue: histoires d'émigration (2014) Les pumas de grande banlieue: histoires d'émigration (2014)
  • Du Grand Rattrapage au Déclin Tranquille: Une histoire économique et sociale du Québec de 1900 à nos jours (2013) Du Grand Rattrapage au Déclin Tranquille: Une histoire économique et sociale du Québec de 1900 à nos jours (2013)
  • Do Império ao Estado: Morfologias do sistema internacional (2013) Do Império ao Estado: Morfologias do sistema internacional (2013)
  • Bemind maar onbekend: de politieke filosofie van het liberalisme (2011) Bemind maar onbekend: de politieke filosofie van het liberalisme (2011)
  • Red Shambhala: Magic, Prophecy, and Geopolitics in the Heart of Asia (2011) Red Shambhala: Magic, Prophecy, and Geopolitics in the Heart of Asia (2011)

In Our Notes

Adam Smith alliances American culture American politics art history Barack Obama Brazil Brexit bureaucracy capitalism China Christianity civil liberty colonialism conservatism constitutionalism coronavirus costs decentralization democracy diplomacy Donald Trump economic development economic growth economic history economics ethics European Union F.A. Hayek federation France free speech free trade geopolitics Germany globalization identity immigration imperialism India inequality institutions international relations Iran Israel Jacques Delacroix knowledge problem liberalism libertarianism Ludwig von Mises maps media studies nationalism political thought populism property rights public choice theory racism RealClearHistory republicanism rule of law Russia scientific method secession socialism state sovereignty Syria taxation terrorism Turkey United Kingdom United States Western culture

Notes from Elsewhere

  • Policy of Truth
  • Marginal Revolution
  • Maggie's Farm
  • Naked Capitalism
  • 3 Quarks Daily
  • Cafe Hayek
  • Alphaville
  • Stumbling and Mumbling
  • Alt-M
  • EconLog
  • Popehat
  • Catallaxy Files
  • Murica Derp
  • Pseudoerasmus
  • Worthwhile Canadian Initiative
  • Samizdata
  • Progressive Geographies
  • TheMoneyIllusion
  • askblog
  • Political Theatre
  • Volokh Conspiracy
  • Law & Liberty
  • Uneasy Money
  • Overcoming Bias
  • All Along the Watchtower
  • Rational Standard
  • Oxford Words
  • Offsetting Behaviour
  • Ottomans & Zionists
  • Uncouth Reflections
  • Less Wrong
  • Goats and Soda
  • OrgTheory
  • Mainly Macro
  • Pragati
  • Power & Market
  • 200-Proof Liberals
  • Crooked Timber
  • Jacobin
  • Radical Classical Liberals
  • Duck of Minerva
  • Disorder of Things
  • Lawyers, Guns & Money
  • JHIBlog
  • Lawfare
  • Angry Bear

Archives of the Notewriters

  • Jacques Delacroix
  • Brandon Christensen
  • Rick Weber
  • Vincent Geloso
  • Barry Stocker
  • Bruno Gonçalves Rosi
  • Michelangelo Landgrave
  • Tridivesh Singh Maini
  • Bill Rein
  • Edwin van de Haar
  • Federico Sosa Valle
  • Chhay Lin Lim
  • Nick Cowen
  • Joakim Book
  • Ethan Blevins
  • Zak Woodman
  • Mark Koyama
  • Kevin Kallmes
  • Mary Lucia Darst
  • Alexander Albrecht
  • Ash Navabi
  • Derrill Watson
  • Lucas G. Freire
  • Andrei Znamenski
  • Shree Agnihotri
  • Adrián Lucardi
  • Lode Cossaer
  • Aris Trantidis

Archives

Blog at WordPress.com.
%d bloggers like this: