A Renegade History of the United States: a brief response

A while ago I finished reading (by audiobook) A Renegade History of the United States. The overarching theme of this entertaining and interesting book often seems to be: “look at these fucking squares!”

And that’s important, because the author points out their illiberal, short sighted, and irrational views, the reactionary nature of those views. But the author turns it into yet another A vs. B situation; a linear spectrum. There’s the “renegades” and the “squares.” I’m absolutely on board with the idea that there are establishment squares to be derided. But just because The Man is stupid, doesn’t mean he’s got a monopoly on it.

The positive message is that “renegades” are exemplars of freedom, and especially the freedom to be wrong. If you aren’t free to make mistakes, you aren’t free. And the point of freedom (besides the fact that freedom is excellent) is that it allows a dispersed approach to figuring out the good life. I’m increasingly doubtful that The Hitchhikers’ Guide was anything but correct when it posited that Earth is a computer set in motion to determine the question that matches the answer to “Life, The Universe, and Everything” (the answer is 42, the question is something besides “What is 6×7?”). This history shows a number of instances that show how breaking from the status quo, actively doing what everyone else is convinced is wrong, contributes to the overall flourishing and success of later generations.

All told, I’m happy giving it 4 stars.

2 thoughts on “A Renegade History of the United States: a brief response

  1. There is a common thread through history of governments being radically conservative and resistant to change to the point of employing violence to maintain the status quo. Liberty is a revolutionary philosophy in that since the establishment of the state there has been an inextricable push for more centralized power and more despotic governments. The great fallacy of the 18th and 19th centuries was that democracy was a move towards greater freedom when in reality it was a move away from it. By providing the illusion of choice and indoctrinating the belief in the Social Contract people now think that there is a separate being from themselves known as “society” or “the public”. Liberty minded individuals need to counter that train of thought, show that there is no greater organization than the individual and destroy the myth of freedom through tyranny known as democracy. Does that make us radical? Absolutely.

  2. “But just because The Man is stupid, doesn’t mean he’s got a monopoly on it.”

    Lol. Now that is a finely turned phrase. Kudos.

Please keep it civil

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s